Buttars’ anti-evolution Bill SB 96 is dead! Victory!
I didn’t expect the House to do it, but they came through. They killed the Bill! The Salt Lake Tribune records its death.
Now I can really enjoy the rest of my vacation here in Sedona. See you all later in the blogosphere.
The evolution bill is no more.The NCSE, and Panda’s Thumb also mention the defeat.
The Utah House of Representatives voted 46-28 to kill SB96, which cast doubt on the teaching of evolution.
"There are a number of influential legislators who believe you evolved from an ape. I didn't," said Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, who sponsored the bill.
He said it was "doubtful" that he would try a similar bill in the future.
The bill would have required a teacher to say the state does not endorse evolution and that the controversial theory is not a proven fact before teaching Charles Darwin's ideas.
SB96's deep religious roots fostered outspoken support among some, such as Rep. LaVar Christensen, and just as fervent opposition from others, like Rep. Stephen Urquhart.
Urquhart, a St. George Republican, first amended the bill, stripping any reference to 'origins of species." The gutted bill simply read: "The State Board of Education shall establish curriculum requirements relating to scientific instruction."
Urquhart opposed Buttars' bill because he doesn't feel that science conflicts with religion and said it was misleading to single out one theory as unproven.
The House voted down the gutted SB96 to stop the Senate from having the ability to revive the issue.
Now I can really enjoy the rest of my vacation here in Sedona. See you all later in the blogosphere.
posted by Thomas Didymus at 8:59 PM
3 Comments:
This was unexpected good news. The one quote that stood out in the Tribune's article was:
'Ferrin said the bill would have counteracted what he believes is the "evangelical zeal" to teach evolution as fact.'
It looks to me like Ferrin was projecting his views onto scientists. Scientists tend to be driven by a desire to understand nature, and not by a desire to propagate belief systems.
Of course, that the bill was about a non-existant thing called the "creation of life" class, indicates that the people writing the bill live in their own little world. My guess is that they have a belief system they want to evangelize and that evolution gets in the way.
Arf!
As Buttars points out... "There are a number of influential legislators who believe you evolved from an ape. I didn't,"
As an intelligent border collie, I would disagree with those influential legislators. By advancing SB 96 the Senate showed all signs that they evolved from sheep not apes. At least the House demonstrated enough
intelligence to indicate that some evolution has happened to our legislature.
Grrrrrrrr.
Hey man, you have to check out www.politic20.com tonight. They are hosting the most interactive political event to date and anyone can be a part of it! I can't believe that the Salt Lake City mayoral candidates are willing to actually go one on one with unedited voters!
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home